Facebook or Fakebook? The effects of simulated mobile applications on simulated mobile networks

The credibility of mobile ad hoc network simulations depends on accurate characterisations of user behaviour, e.g., mobility and application usage. If simulated nodes communicate at different rates to real nodes, or move in an unrealistic fashion, this may have a large impact on the network protocols being simulated and tested. Many future mobile network protocols, however, may also depend on future mobile applications. Different applications may be used at different rates or in different manners. But how can we determine realistic user behaviour for such applications that do not yet exist? One common solution is again simulation, but this time simulation of these future applications. This paper examines differences in user behaviour between a real and simulated mobile social networking application through a user study (n=80). We show that there are distinct differences in privacy behaviour between the real and simulated groups. We then simulate a mobile opportunistic network application using two real-world traces to demonstrate the impact of using real and simulated applications. We find large differences between using real and synthetic models of privacy behaviour, but smaller differences between models derived from the real and simulated applications. ∗Corresponding author. Email addresses: [email protected] (Iain Parris), [email protected] (Fehmi Ben Abdesslem), [email protected] (Tristan Henderson) URL: http://www.cs.st-andrews.ac.uk/∼ip/ (Iain Parris), http://www.cs.st-andrews.ac.uk/∼fehmi/ (Fehmi Ben Abdesslem), http://www.cs.st-andrews.ac.uk/∼tristan/ (Tristan Henderson) Phone: +44 1334 463253 Fax: +44 1334 463278 Preprint submitted to Ad Hoc Networks January 31, 2012